# +7 (495) 645 80 10

Reform of system of penalties in Russia can be useful to citizens

Marina Krasnobayeva explained, what purpose Head pursues YOU the Russian Federation Anton Ivanov who suggests to change system of imposing of penalties so that concordant with punishment could be limited to payment of a half of the sum, and those who argues because of a penalty in court, loses and all the same doesn’t pay, – would receive punishment in the form of obligatory works or arrest.

Head YOU the Russian Federation Anton Ivanov suggests to change system of imposing of penalties so that concordant with punishment could be limited to payment of a half of the sum, and those who argues because of a penalty in court, loses and all the same doesn’t pay, – would receive punishment in the form of obligatory works or arrest.

MOSCOW, 23 aching — РАПСИ. The new system of collecting the penalties, offered by the chairman of the Supreme Arbitration Court (YOU) the Russian Federation Anton Ivanov, can be favorable to citizens, but to introduce it it is necessary with care, the experts interrogated on Friday РАПСИ consider.

Head YOU the Russian Federation suggests to change system of imposing of penalties so that concordant with punishment could be limited to payment of a half of the sum, and those who argues because of a penalty in court, loses and all the same doesn’t pay — would receive punishment in the form of obligatory works or arrest, the Vedomosti newspaper wrote to Friday. Ivanov plans to bring the initiative at coming nearer Congress of judges of the Russian Federation.

Dmitry Lipatov, the partner of the Nalogovik company, considers the offer “very interesting”, and, in his opinion, despite obvious aiming of an initiative at citizens, it would help also to businessmen.

“In practice of check of business by supervisory authorities often terminate in threat of pronouncement of the resolution on attraction to administrative responsibility in the form of a penalty. Corrupted checking sometimes suggest the businessman not to make it answerable for a bribe in 30-50 % from a penalty. It is easy to present, how many money is in a shadow corruption turn. If to violators will give the chance to “be given” voluntary, at their expense it is possible to fill up the budget” — Lipatov explained.

According to the senior lawyer of Bar “Yukov and partners” Marina Krasnobayeva, Ivanov’s initiative pursues the purpose to unload the judicial system overloaded with disputes on the appeal of resolutions on collecting penalties.

“As far as we know from open sources, earlier for achievement of this purpose Ivanov wanted to raise the state taxes for consideration of a number of categories of affairs, but received basic objections from the Ministry of Finance. Now it turns out that if “violator” understands hopelessness of contest of the resolution, it doesn’t go to court and receives for it less high penalty, than it is provided by KOAP Russian Federation as the consent it saves expenses of vessels” — Krasnobayeva noted.

She especially emphasized that in this initiative there is nothing bad for citizens as them nobody deprives of the right to the appeal of resolutions.

“As to the companies, here it is necessary to agree with those who considers the matter needing detailed study — it is necessary to approach differentially to separate types of penalties as development of the general principle will be hardly effective” — the interlocutor of agency considers.

According to Dmitry Lipatov, the initiative has also minuses in that part which concern toughening of responsibility for penalty failure to pay. The expert pays attention that at us many citizens live not in a place of registration that disturbs them вовре

Comments are closed.